Anàlisi crítica del mecanisme rural de garantia com a instrument de política pública: lliçons internacionals

Autors/ores

Resum

El mecanisme rural de garantia (MRG) es defineix com «un intent de garantir que totes les àrees polítiques tinguin en compte els problemes rurals». El plantejament és aparentment simple i molt atractiu, però alhora esdevé tremendament complex. En aquest article, a més de repassar-hi el marc europeu, s’hi analitzen amb detall tres experiències especialment rellevants: la del Canadà, que van ser els pioners (des de 1998 fins a 2013); la d’Anglaterra, que és el model més robust i consolidat, encara que amb diferents ajustos al llarg de la seva història (des de 2000 fins a l’actualitat), i un model, el d’Irlanda, que està naixent, però que presenta novetats i que intenta aplicar les lliçons apreses fins ara (des de 2021 fins a l’actualitat). Aquestes anàlisis diferents ens permeten extreure’n una sèrie de lliçons de cara a calibrar adequadament, sense expectatives infundades, els elements fonamentals d’un MRG adequat que, en tot cas, ha de ser flexible i adaptar-se a les circumstàncies nacionals, regionals i locals.

Paraules clau

mecanisme rural de garantia, rural proofing, desenvolupament rural, avaluació de polítiques públiques, adaptació territorial, experiències internacionals

Referències

ALMEIDA, V. et al. (2024). «Geographic inequalities in accessibility of essential services». OECD Social, Employment and Migration Working Papers, 307. París: OECD Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/12bab9fb-en

ATTERTON, J. (2008). Rural proofing in England: A formal commitment in need of review. Centre for Rural Economy Discussion Paper Series. University of Newcastle upon Tyne.

ATTERTON, J. (2019). Learning Lessons from early Islands Communities Impact Assessments. Rural Policy Centre, 49 p. Recuperado de https://pure.sruc.ac.uk/en/publications/learning-lessons-from-early-islands-communities-impact-assessment

ATTERTON, J. (2022). Analytical overview of rural proofing approaches and lessons learned. ENRD Thematic Group Rural Proofing – Background document, 7 p. Recuperado de https://ec.europa.eu/enrd/enrd-thematic-work/long-term-rural-vision/TG-rural-proofing_en_en.html

BRYCE, B. (2024). «Rural Proofing: Lessons from OECD countries and potential application to health». OECD Regional Development Papers, 73. París: OECD Publishing, 61 p. https://doi.org/10.1787/4011899a-en

COMISIÓN EUROPEA (2016). Declaración de Cork 2-0: Una vida mejor en el medio rural. Recuperado de https://ec.europa.eu/enrd/cork-20-and-future-rural-development_es.html

COMISIÓN EUROPEA (2021a). Una visión a largo plazo para las zonas rurales de la UE: Hacia unas zonas rurales más fuertes, conectadas, resilientes y prósperas antes de 2040. COM(2021) 345 final. Bruselas (30 de junio). Recuperado de https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=COM:2021:345:FIN

COMISIÓN EUROPEA (2021b). Action Plan: Rural proofing. Recuperado de https://rural-vision.europa.eu/action-plan/cross-cutting/rural-proofing_en

COMISIÓN EUROPEA (2024). Rural Vision: Plan de Acción Rural. Recuperado de https://rural-vision.europa.eu/action-plan_es?prefLang=es#zonas-rurales-más-fuertes

DEFRA (2013). Guide to Rural Proofing: National guidelines. Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs, p. 8. Recuperado de https://www.ruralsussex.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/DEFRA-Guide-to-Rural-Proofing-National-Guidelines-2013.pdf

DEFRA (2021). Rural proofing in England 2020: Delivering policy in a rural context (26 de marzo). Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs. Recuperado de https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/rural-proofing-in-england-2020

DEFRA (2022a). Delivering for rural England: The second report on rural proofing (3 de septiembre) [Documento de orientación]. Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs. Recuperado de https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/delivering-for-rural-england

DEFRA (2022b). Rural proofing: Practical guidance to consider outcomes of policies in rural areas. Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (noviembre). Recuperado de https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/rural-proofing

DEFRA (2023). Policy Paper: Unleashing rural opportunity (6 de junio). Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs. Recuperado de https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/unleashing-rural-opportunity/unleashing-rural-opportunity#growing-the-rural-economy

DEFRA (2024). Policy Paper. Delivering rural opportunity: Third report on rural proofing (18 de mayo). Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs. Recuperado de https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/delivering-rural-opportunity/delivering-rural-opportunity-third-report-on-rural-proofing#communities-1

DEPARTMENT OF THE ENVIRONMENT, TRANSPORT AND THE REGIONS. DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, FISHERIES AND FOOD (2000). Our Countryside: The future. Rural White Paper. 176 p. Recuperado de https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukgwa/20050301192907/http:/defra.gov.uk/rural/pdfs/ruralwp/rural.pdf

DOMÍNGUEZ, J. L. (2021). «El avance del ‘rural proofing’ o ‘mecanismo rural de garantía’ como herramienta indispensable para afrontar el reto demográfico y territorial». En: BUJOSA, L. M. (dir.). Administración, hacienda y justicia en el Estado Social II. Valencia: Tirant lo Blanch, 171-191.

ESPARCIA, J. (2025). «Towards Rural Proofing – in Spain –: (Un)Founded Expectations?». Boletín de la Asociación Española de Geografía, 103, 33 p.

EUROPEAN NETWORK FOR RURAL DEVELOPMENT (ENRD) (2022). Rural Proofing: Putting rural proofing into practice. 1st meeting of Thematic Group (27 de enero), y 2nd meeting of Thematic Group (19 de mayo). Recuperado de https://ec.europa.eu/enrd/rural-proofing_es.html

GAUGITSCH, R.; MESSINGER, I.; NEUGEBAUER, W.; SCHUH, B.; TOPTSIDOU, M. y BÖHGME, K. (2022). Rural proofing: A foresight framework for resilient rural communities. European Committee of the Regions, 78 p. http://dx.doi.org/10.2863/542366

GOVERNMENT OF IRELAND (2021a). Our Rural Future: Rural Development Policy 2021-2025. Recuperado de https://www.socialjustice.ie/content/policy-issues/our-rural-future-rural-development-policy-2021-2025

GOVERNMENT OF IRELAND (2021b). Our Rural Future: Annual Work Programme. Department of Rural and Community Development. Recuperado de https://www.gov.ie/en/collection/bcbca-our-rural-future-annual-work-programmes-and-progress-reports/

GOVERNMENT OF IRELAND (2022). Our Rural Future: Annual Work Programme. Department of Rural and Community Development. Recuperado de https://www.gov.ie/en/collection/bcbca-our-rural-future-annual-work-programmes-and-progress-reports/

GOVERNMENT OF IRELAND (2023a). Our Rural Future. Progress Report 5 – Q4 2023. Recuperado de https://www.gov.ie/en/collection/bcbca-our-rural-future-annual-work-programmes-and-progress-reports/

GOVERNMENT OF IRELAND (2023b). Our Rural Future: Annual Work Programme 2023. Department of Rural and Community Development. Recuperado de https://www.gov.ie/en/collection/bcbca-our-rural-future-annual-work-programmes-and-progress-reports/

GOVERNMENT OF IRELAND (2024a). Our Rural Future: Annual Work Programme 2024. Department of Rural and Community Development. Recuperado de https://www.gov.ie/en/collection/bcbca-our-rural-future-annual-work-programmes-and-progress-reports/

GOVERNMENT OF IRELAND (2024b). Our Rural Future. Progress Report 6 – Q2 2024. Recuperado de https://www.gov.ie/en/collection/bcbca-our-rural-future-annual-work-programmes-and-progress-reports/

HALL, H. y GIBSON, R. (2016). Rural Proofing in Canada: An Examination of the Rural Secretariat and the Rural Lens. Recuperado de https://ruraldev.ca/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/RuralProofinginCanada-HallGibson.pdf [Fecha de consulta: 24/05/2024).

HUSBERG, A. (2022). «Finish experiences on rural proofing». Rural Proofing: Putting rural proofing into practice. 1st meeting of Thematic Group (27 de enero). European Network for Rural Development (ENRD). Recuperado de https://ec.europa.eu/enrd/rural-proofing_es.html

JUNG, M. S. (2021). Institutional Framework and Prospects of the Quality of Rural Life Policy in Korea. Taipei: FFTC Agricultural Policy Platform (FFTC-AP). Recuperado de https://ap.fftc.org.tw/article/2950

KASEMETS, A. y KURVITS, T. (2022). How to make the regional impact assessment, rural proofing, a routine part of the decision-making process of officials across the government, in all ministries?: Some ideas and examples from Estonia. European Network for Rural Development. Recuperado de https://ec.europa.eu/enrd/rural-proofing_es.html

KOREA RURAL ECONOMIC INSTITUTE (2024). Rural Proofing: Research Reports Serie. Recuperado de https://www.krei.re.kr/eng/research.do?key=355&pageType=010101&searchCnd=all&searchKrwd=rural+proofing

MANTINO, F.; FORCINA, B.; VIRONEN, H.; FONSEJA, L. y KAHILA, P. (2023). Review of rural proofing instruments and experiences in European and non-European countries (RUSTIK) [Esquema del informe] (31 de octubre), 43 p. Recuperado de https://rustik-he.eu/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/D1.3-Report-on-rural-proofing-1.pdf

MOSELEY, M. (2023). Accessibility: The Rural Challenge. Londres: Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781003429333

MOSELEY, M. y PARKER, G. (1998). The Joint Provision of Rural Services [Informe]. Salisbury: Rural Development Commission, 124 p.

NORDBERG, K. (2021). «Distributed Rural Proofing – An Essential Tool for the Future of Rural Development?». Sociologia Ruralis, 61 (1), 141-162. https://doi.org/10.1111/soru.12316

OECD (2011). OECD Rural Policy Reviews: England, United Kingdom. OECD Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/9789264094444-en

OECD (2020). Rural Well-being: Geography of Opportunities. París: OECD Rural Studies. OECD Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/d25cef80-en

OECD (2023). Government at a Glance 2023: Ireland [Nota sobre el país]. Recuperado de https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/government-at-a-glance-2023_c4200b14-en/ireland_cbfad650-en.html

OECD (2024). Getting to Services in Towns and Villages: Preparing Regions for Demographic Change. París: OECD Rural Studies. OECD Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/df1e9b88-en

PARNELL, W. y LYNCH, W. (2023a). Proposals for an effective Rural Proofing model for Ireland. Department of Rural and Community Development. configur, 84 p. Recuperado de https://www.gov.ie/en/collection/06a3d-rural-proofing-proposals-for-a-rural-proofing-model-for-ireland/

PARNELL, W. y LYNCH, W. (2023b). Proposals for an effective Rural Proofing model for Ireland. Appendix 1: Suggested Guidelines for Rural Proofing. Department of Rural and Community Development. Government of Ireland, 15 p. Recuperado de https://www.gov.ie/en/collection/06a3d-rural-proofing-proposals-for-a-rural-proofing-model-for-ireland/

PARNELL, W. y LYNCH, W. (2023c). Proposals for an effective Rural Proofing model for Ireland. Appendix 2: Suggested Rural Impact Assessment Template. Department of Rural and Community Development. Government of Ireland, 9 p. Recuperado de https://www.gov.ie/en/collection/06a3d-rural-proofing-proposals-for-a-rural-proofing-model-for-ireland/

PICÓN, A. (2023). «Estudio comparado del denominado “Mecanismo rural de garantía”. Una propuesta para Castilla y León». Revista de estudios de la Administración Local y Autonómica. Nueva Época, 20, 124-145. https://doi.org/10.24965/reala.11234

RED ESPAÑOLA DE DESARROLLO RURAL (REDR) (2023). Lo rural, ¡escalando posiciones!: El Rural Proofing como herramienta para transversalizar lo rural a nivel nacional o internacional. Recuperado de https://redrjovenes.redr.es/2023/04/27/lo-rural-escalando-posiciones-la-nueva-publicacion-de-redr-sobre-rural-proofing/

RED ESPAÑOLA DE DESARROLLO RURAL (REDR) (2024a). Rural Proofing. Ruralizando las políticas que afectan al medio rural: Experiencias nacionales e internacionales. Recuperado de https://ruralproofing.redr.es/index.php/ruralizando-medio-rural/

RED ESPAÑOLA DE DESARROLLO RURAL (REDR) (2024b). Guía de Rural Proofing para la evaluación de la perspectiva rural en leyes, políticas, planes y estrategias. Recuperado de https://www.redr.es/es/noticias/ponte-las-gafas-rurales-redr-elabora-una-guia-practica-sobre-rural-proofing/

RED EUROPEA DE DESARROLLO RURAL (REDR) (2017). «Enfoque en…: El mecanismo rural de garantía». Rural Connections: La Revista sobre Desarrollo Rural Europeo. European Network for Rural Development (otoño/invierno), 26-38. Recuperado de https://ec.europa.eu/enrd/publications/rural-connections-magazine-autumn-winter-2017-edition_es.html

REWHORN, S. A. (2019). A Critical Review of Rural Proofing in England [Tesis doctoral]. University of Chester, UK, 186 p. Recuperado de http://hdl.handle.net/10034/622858

RURAL SERVICES NETWORK (2024). Rural Lens Review on DEFRA’s third Rural Proofing Report for 2024 (abril). Recuperado de https://www.rsnonline.org.uk/rural-lens-review-on-defras-third-rural-proofing-report-for-2024

SANZ, J.; SORIANO, S.; HERRERO, J. y PAZOS-VIDAL, S. (2023). «El ‘rural proofing’ o ‘mecanismo rural de garantía’ como instrumento de dinamización de las áreas rurales». En: GÓMEZ, Y. (coord.). Despoblación, cohesión territorial e igualdad de derechos. Madrid: Centro de Estudios Políticos y Constitucionales, 117-155.

SHERRY, E. y SHORTALL, S. (2019). «Methodological fallacies and perceptions of rural disparity: How rural proofing addresses real versus abstract needs». Journal of Rural Studies, 68, 336-343. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jrurstud.2018.12.005

SHORTALL, S. y ALSTON, M. (2016). «To Rural Proof or Not To Rural Proof: A Comparative Analysis». Politics & Policy, 44 (1), 35-55. https://doi.org/10.1111/polp.12144

SHORTALL, S. y SHERRY, E. (2018). Rural Proofing in Northern Ireland: An overview and recommendations on guidance, implementation and governance. Centre for Rural Economy. Newcastle University. Recuperado de https://www.afbini.gov.uk/publications/rural-proofing-northern-ireland-overview-and-recommendations

SHORTALL, S. y SHERRY, E. (2022). «Rural Policy/Rural Proofing in Northern Ireland. ENRD - European Network for Rural Development». Rural Proofing: Putting rural proofing into practice. 1st meeting of Thematic Group (27 de enero). Recuperado de https://ec.europa.eu/enrd/rural-proofing_es.html

SUTARSA, N.; CAMPBELL, L. y MOORE, M. (2021). «Rural Proofing Policies for Health: Barriers to Policy Transfer for Australia». Social Sciences, 10 (9), 338. https://doi.org/10.3390/socsci10090338

Publicades

31-01-2025

Com citar

Esparcia Pérez, J. (2025). Anàlisi crítica del mecanisme rural de garantia com a instrument de política pública: lliçons internacionals. Documents d’Anàlisi Geogràfica, 71(1), 33–63. https://doi.org/10.5565/rev/dag.936

Descàrregues

Les dades de descàrrega encara no estan disponibles.