Planning, Justice and LGBT Urban Politics in Tel-Aviv: A Queer Dilemma

Chen Misgav

doi:10.5565/rev/dag.580

Planning, Justice and LGBT Urban Politics in Tel-Aviv: A Queer Dilemma

Authors

Chen Misgav The Open University

PDF

Abstract

The paper discusses planning policies and urban politics, their relation to LGBT communities in the city, and their potential to promote spatial justice within the local planning policies. The paper briefly reviews the main theoretical issues discussed in the literature regarding the connection between planning and sexuality. It also reviews three theoretical concepts of justice that relate to planning policy and urban politics: distributive Justice, procedural justice and recognition. The case study of the Gay Center at Tel Aviv’s Meir Park is analyzed with reference to these three spatial justice concepts. The main argument is that the center is a clear example of distributive and procedural justice. However, when we analyze this case study in light of the concept of recognition, the findings are somewhat ambiguous. On the one hand, the case of the Gay Center indicates growing recognition of Tel Aviv’s LGBT community. On the other hand, a queer analysis shows that this recognition is partial as it is limited to certain parts of the community and to spaces frequented by LGBTs in Tel-Aviv.

Keywords

planning, justice, urban politics, LGBT community, queer, Israel

References

ADLER, S. and BRENNER, J. (1992). “Gender and space: Lesbians and gay men in the city”. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 16, 24-34.

ALFASI, N. (2006). “Creative cities: Jerusalem, Tel Aviv and the new economy”. Israeli Sociology, 8 (1), 29-64 (Hebrew).

ALFASI, N. and FENSTER, T. (2005). “A tale of two cities: Jerusalem and Tel Aviv in an age of globalization”. Cities, 22 (5), 351-363.

ALFASI, N. and FENSTER, T. (2014). “Between socio-spatial and urban justice: Rawls’ principles of justice in the 2011 Israeli Protest Movement”. Planning Theory, 13 (4), 407-427. https://doi.org/10.1177/1473095214521105

ALLWEIL, Y. (2003). “Why did they turn off the lights in Electricity Park?”. In: MORIA, Y. and BARNIR, S. (eds.). In the Public Domain: A Tribute to Tel Aviv’s Municipal Gardener Avraham Karavan. Tel Aviv: Tel Aviv Museum, 101-105 (Hebrew).

ANDRUCKI, M. and ELDER, G. S. (2007). “Locating the state in queer space: GLBT non-profit organizations in Vermont, USA”. Social and Cultural Geography, 8 (1), 89-104.

BELL, D. and VALENTINE, G. (eds.) (1995). Mapping Desire: Geographies of Sexualities. London: Routledge.

BALNERO, R. and FRIDMAN, A. (2001). The Pink Survey. Tel Aviv: The Center for Social and Economic Research in Tel Aviv-Jaffa Municipality (Hebrew).

BAUM, D. (2006). “Women in black and men in pink: Protesting against the Israeli occupation”. Social Identities, 12 (5), 563-574.

BELL, D. and BINNIE, J. (2004). “Authenticating queer space: Citizenship, urbanism and governance”. Urban Studies, 41 (9), 1807-1820.

BILESKI, L. (2011). “‘Before that we did not trespass’: The city, the woman and the drifter in the Yaakobowitz Trial”. The Law: Law Review, 16 (1-2), 131-172 (Hebrew).

BROWN, P. M. (2008) “Working political geography through social movements theory: The case of gay and lesbian Seattle. In: COX, K.; LOW, M. and ROBINSON, J. (eds.). The SAGE Handbook of Political Geography. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 285-304.

BROWNE, K.; LIM, J. and BROWN, G. (eds.) (2007). Geographies of Sexualities: Theory, Practices and Politics. Farnham and Burlington, UK: Ashgate.

CAMPBELL, H. (2006). “Just planning: The art of situated ethical judgment”. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 26, 92-106.

CASTELLS, M. (1983). The City and the Grassroots. Berkeley: University of California Press.

CHAUNCEY, G. (1994). Gay New York: Gender, Urban Culture, and the Making of the Gay Male World, 1890-1940. New York: Basic Books.

COOK, M. and EVANS, J. V. (2014). Queer Cities, Queer Cultures: Europe since 1945. London and New-York: Bloomsbury.

CHURCHMAN, A. (2012). “Protecting groups at the margins of the planning system: Procedural justice as a means”. In: HASSON, S. (ed.). Shaping the Space in Israel: The Map of Lands and Settlements. Jerusalem: Keter and JNF, 289-300 (Hebrew).

DAHAN, Y. (2007). Theories of Social Justice. Tel Aviv: Tel Aviv University and Ministry of Defense, The Broadcast University (Hebrew).

DOAN, P. L. (2010). “The tyranny of gendered spaces: Reflections from beyond the gender dichotomy”. Gender, Place and Culture: A Journal of Feminist Geography, 17 (5), 635-654.

DOAN, P. L. (ed.) (2011). Queerying Planning: Challenging Heteronormative Assumptions and Reframing Planning Practice. Farnham and Burlington, UK: Ashgate.

DOAN, P. L. (2015a). Planning and LGBTQ Communities: The Need for Inclusive Queer Spaces. Abingdon: Routledge.

DOAN, P. L. (2015b). “Regulating adult business to make spaces safe for heterosexual families in Atlanta”. In: MAGINN, P. J and STEINMETZ, C. (eds.). (Sub)Urban Sexualities: Geographies and Regulation of the sex Industry. Abingdon: Routledge, 197-218.

DOAN, P. L. (2015c). “Planning for sexual and gender minorities”. In: BURAYID, M. (ed.). Cities and the Politics of Difference: Multiculturalism and diversity in Planning. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 135-158.

DOAN, P. L. (2015d). “Beyond queer space: Planning for diverse and dispersed LGBTQ populations”. In: DOAN, P. (ed.). Planning and LGBTQ Communities: The Need for Inclusive Queer Spaces. Abingdon: Routledge, 251-259.

DOAN, P. L. (2016). “Is there a place in the progressive city for the LGBTQ community?”. Progressive City (16 Oct, 2016), available at: http://www.progressivecity.net/single-post/2016/10/05/IS-THERE-A-PLACE-IN-THE-PROGRESSIVE-CITY-FOR-THE-LGBTQ-COMMUNITY

DOAN, P. L. and HIGGINS, H. (2011). The demise of queer space? Resurgent gentrification and LGBT neighborhoods. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 31 (1), 6-25.

DUBROW, G. and CORBIN-SIES (2002). “Letting our guard down: Race, class, gender and sexuality in planning history”. Journal of Planning History, 1 (3), 203-214.

DUBROW, G., KNOPP, L. and BROWN, M. (2015). “Act Up versus Straighten Up: Public Policy and Queer Community-Based Activism”. In: DOAN, P. (ed). Planning and LGBTQ Communities: The Need for Inclusive Queer Spaces. Abingdon: Routledge, 202-216.

DUGGAN, L. (2002). “The new homonormativity: The sexual politics of neoliberalism”. In: R. CASTRONOVO and D. D. NELSON (eds.). Materializing Democracy: Towards a Revitalized Cultural Politics. Duke: Duke University Press, 175-194.

EGERTT, Y. (2007). The City Center for the LGBT Community: Social-Physical Program. Tel Aviv: Tel-Aviv-Jaffa Municipality, Administration of Education, Culture and Sport (Hebrew).

EISNER, S. (2012). “Love, rage and the occupation: Bisexual politics in Israel/Palestine”. Journal of Bisexuality, 12 (1), 80-137.

ELAD, H. (2008). “In Jerusalem, separation walls are visible from the route of the Pride Parade”. In: KATZ, Y., DEGANI, Z. and GROS, T. (eds.). Somewhere Here: Language, Identity, Place. Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuchad, 252-276 (Hebrew).

FAINSTEIN, S. (2010). The Just City. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

FENSTER, T. (2004). The Global City and the Holy City: Narratives on Planning, Knowledge and Diversity. London: Pearson

FENSTER, T. and MANOR, I. (2010). “Homo-lesbian citizenship in the urban space of Tel Aviv and Jerusalem”. Israeli Sociology, 12 (1), 7-28 (Hebrew).

FINCHER, R. and IVESON, K. (2008). Planning and Diversity in the City. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

FINCHER, R.; IVESON, K.; LEITNER, H. and PRESTON, V. (2014). “Planning in the multicultural city: Celebrating diversity or reinforcing difference?”. Progress in Planning, 92, 1-55.

FLORIDA, R. (2004). Cities and the Creative Class. London and New-York: Routledge.

FORSYTH, A. (2001). Sexuality and space: Nonconformist populations and planning practice. Journal of Planning Literature, 15 (3), 339-358.

FRASER, N. (2004). “From distribution to recognition? The dilemma of justice in the ‘post-socialist era’”. In: FILK, D. and RAM, O. (eds.). The Power of Property: Israeli Society in the Global Age. Tel Aviv and Jerusalem: Hakibbutz Hameuchad and Van Leer Institute, 270-297 (Hebrew).

FREEDMAN, M. (1990). Exile in the Promised Land: A Memoir. Ann Arbor: Firebrand Books.

FRISCH, M. (2002). “Planning as a Heterosexist Project”. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 21 (3), 254-266.

GOH, K. (2015). “Place/Out: Planning for Radical Queer Activism”. In: DOAN, P. (ed.). Planning and LGBTQ Communities: The Need for Inclusive Queer Spaces. Abingdon: Routledge, 217-234.

GORMAN-MURRAY, A. (2011). “Queering planning in Australia: The problems and possibilities of multiscalar governance for LGBT sexual minorities”. In: DOAN, P. (ed.). Queerying planning: Challenging heteronormative assumptions and reframing planning practice. Farnham: Ashgate, 129-143.

GORMAN-MURRAY, A. and NASH, C. (2014). “Mobile places, relational spaces: conceptualizing change in Sydney’s LGBTQ neighborhoods”. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 32 (4), 622-641.

GROSS, A. (2015). The politics of LGBT rights in Israel and beyond: Nationality, normality, and queer politics. Columbia Human Rights Law Review, 46 (2), 81-152.

GROSS, A. and ZIV, A. (2003). “Between theory and politics: Homo-lesbian studies and queer theory”. In: KEIDAR, Y., ZIV, A. and KANER, A. (eds.). Beyond Sexuality: A Selection of Articles in Homo-Lesbian Studies and Queer Theory. Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuchad, 9-44 (Hebrew).

HAREL, A. (1999). “The rise and fall of the Israeli gay legal revolution”. Columbia Human Rights Law Review, 31, 443-471.

HARTAL, G. (2015). “The gendered politics of absence: Homonationalism and gendered power relations in Tel Aviv’s Gay-Center”. In: BROWNE, K. (ed.). Lesbian Geographies: Gender, Place and Power. Aldershot, UK: Ashgate, 91-112.

HARTAL, G. and SASSON-LEVY, O. (2017). “Being [in] the center: Sexual citizenship and homonationalism at Tel Aviv’s Gay-Center”. Sexualities, 20 (5-6), 738-761.

HARTAL, G. and SASSON-LEVY, O. (2018). “Re-Reading Homonationalism: An Israeli Spatial Perspective”. Journal of Homosexuality, 65 (10), 1391-1414.

HARVEY, D. (1973). Social Justice and the City. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.

HASSON, S. (2001). “The evolvement of neighborhood activism and the extension of citizenship rights”. Israel Affairs, 7 (4), 45-64.

HEALEY, P. (1997). Collaborative Planning: Shaping Places in Fragmented Societies. London: Macmillan Press.

HIGGS, D. (ed.) (1999). Queer Sites: Gay Urban Histories since 1600. London and New York: Routledge.

HIRSH, D. (2005). “Homotopia: Independence Park in Tel Aviv”. In: KLOSH, R. and CHATUKA T. (eds.). Architectural Culture, Place, Representation, Body. Tel Aviv: Resling, 287-310 (Hebrew).

HUBBARD, P. (2012). Cities and Sexualities. London and New-York: Routledge.

JOHNSTON, L. and LONGHURST, R. (2010). Space, Place and Sex, Geographies of Sexualities. Plymouth, UK: Rowman & Littlefield

JOHNSTON, L. and VALENTINE, G. (1995). “Wherever I lay my girlfriend, that’s my home: The performance and surveillance of lesbian identities in domestic Environments”. In: BELL, D. and VALENTINE, G. (eds.). Mapping Desire. London: Routledge, 76-99.

KAMA, A. (2000). “From terra incognita to terra firma: The logbook of the voyage of gay men’s community into the Israeli public sphere”. Journal of Homosexuality, 38 (4), 133-162.

KAMA, A. (2011). “Parading pridefully into the mainstream: Gay and lesbian immersion in the civil core”. In: BEN-PORAT, G. and TURNER, B. (eds.). The Contradictions of Israeli Citizenship: Land, Religion and State. New York: Routledge.

KAMA, A. (2014). “Calculating hedonism among gay men”. In: LEITNER M. J. and LEITNER S. (eds.). Israeli Life and Leisure in the 21st Century. Urbana, IL: Sagamore Publishing, 281-290.

KENNEY, M. R. (2001). Mapping Gay L.A: The Interaction of Place and Politics. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.

KIPNIS, B. (2009). “Greater Tel Aviv as a ‘global city’: Hub in a global network and ‘disproportional head’ in Israeli space”. In: KIPNIS, B. (ed.). Tel Aviv Jaffa: From a Garden Suburb to World City: The First One Hundred Years. Haifa: Pardes, 227-260 (Hebrew).

LAURIA, M. and KNOOP, L. (1985). “Towards an analysis of the role of gay communities in the urban renaissance”. Urban Geography, 6, 651-669.

LEVIN, M. (1979). Gay Men: The Sociology of Male Homosexuality. New York: Harper and Row.

MAGINN, P. and STEINMETZ, C. (2015) (eds). (Sub)Urban Sexscapes: Geographies and regulation of sex industry. London and New York: Routledge.

MARCUSE, P. (2012). “Justice”. In: WEBER, R. and CRANE, R. (eds.). Oxford Handbook of Urban Planning. New York: Oxford University Press, 141-165.

MARCUSE, P. (2014). “Sustainability and justice: Goals of the cities of tomorrow”. In: FENSTER, T. and SHLOMO, A. (eds.). Cities of Tomorrow: Planning, Justice and Sustainability Today. Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuchad, 25-40 (Hebrew).

MISGAV, C. (2008). “The urban space in Tel Aviv-Yafo as viewed by gay people”. IGU- International Geographical Union, the Worldwide Conference, (Aug., 2008), Tunis, Tunisia.

MARCUSE, P. (2015a). “With the current, against the wind: Constructing spatial activism and radical politics in Tel Aviv’s LGBT Community Center”. ACME: An International E-Journal for Critical Geography, 14 (4), 1208-1234.

MARCUSE, P. (2015b). “Planning, justice and LGBT urban politics: The case of Tel Aviv’s Gay-Center”. Tichnon – Journal of the Israeli Planning Association (special issue on planning and justice edited by Oren Yiftachel and Rani Mendelbaum), 12 (1), 180-195. (Hebrew).

MARCUSE, P. (2016). “Gay-Riatrics: Spatial politics and activism of elderly gay men in Tel-Aviv’s Gay Community Center”. Gender, Place and Culture: A Journal of Feminist Geography, 23 (11), 1519-1534.

MORENO, A. (2011). Proud in the Center: Neo-Liberal Governmentality and Individualization Processes in the LGBT Community in Israel. MA thesis, Tel-Aviv University (Hebrew).

MORT, F. (2000). “The sexual geography of the city”. In: BRIDGE, G. and WATSON, S. (eds.). A Companion to the City. Oxford: Blackwell, 307-315.

MULLER-MYRDAHL, T. (2011). “Queerying creative cities”. In: DOAN, P. (ed.). Queerying Planning: Challenging Heteronormative Assumptions and Reframing Planning Practice. Farnham and Burlington, UK: Ashgate, 157-168.

NASH, C. and GORMAN-MURRAY, A. (2015). “Recovering the gay village: a comparative historical geography of urban change and planning in Toronto and Sydney”. Historical Geography, 43, 84-105.

NASH, C. and GORMAN-MURRAY, A. (2014). “LGBT neighbourhoods and ‘new mobilities’: towards understanding transformations in sexual and gendered urban landscapes”. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 38 (3), 756-772.

NAST, H. (2002). “Queer patriarchies, queer racisms, international”. Antipode, 34, 874-909.

PIZMONY-LEVY, O. (2005). A City Center for the LGBT Community in Tel-Aviv-Jaffa: Needs Survey Findings. Tel Aviv: The Committee for Human Rights, Tel Aviv-Jaffa Municipality (Hebrew).

PRIOR, J. and GORMAN-MURRAY, A. (2015). Housing sex within the city: The placement of sex services beyond respectable domesticity. In: MAGINN, P. and STEINMETZ, C. (eds.). (Sub)Urban Sexscapes: Geographies and regulation of sex industry. London and New York: Routledge, 101-116.

PUAR, J. K. (2007). Terrorist Assemblages: Homonationalism in Queer Times. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

QUILLEY, S. (1997). “Constructing Manchester’s new urban village: Gay spaces in the entrepreneurial city”. In: BRENT, G. et al. (eds.). Queers in Space: Communities, Public Spaces, Sites of Resistance. Washington: Bay Press, 192-275.

RICHARDSON, D. (2005). “Desiring sameness? The rise of a neoliberal politics of normalization”. Antipode, 37, 515-535.

RONSBO, H. (2006). “Displacing Enigma and Shaping Communal Hegemony – Towards the Analysis of Violent Experience as Social Process”. Dialectical Anthropology, 30 (1), 47-67.

ROSNER, M. (2003). “Sociological and psychological approaches for social justice and equality in the post-industrial era”. In: YASOUR, A., OVED, Y., ROSOLIO, D., and ROSNER, M. (eds.). Social Justice and Equality in a Changing World. Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuchad, 89-158 (Hebrew).

RUEZ, D. (2016). “Working to appear: The plural and uneven geographies of race, sexuality, and the local state in Sydney, Australia”. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 34 (2), 282-300.

SANDERCOCK, L. (1998a). Toward Cosmopolis. Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons.

SANDERCOCK, L. (ed.) (1998b). Making the Invisible Visible: A Multicultural Planning History. Berkeley: University of California Press.

SCHOTTEN, C. H. (2016). “Homonationalism”. International Feminist Journal of Politics, 18 (3), 351-370.

SCHULMAN, S. (2012). Israel/Palestine and the Queer International. Durham and London: Duke University Press.

SWIRSKI, S. (1989). Israel: The Oriental Majority. London: Zed Books.

TEL AVIV-JAFFA MUNICIPALITY (2002). The City’s Profile: October 2002. Tel Aviv: Author (Hebrew).

TEL AVIV-JAFFA MUNICIPALITY (2005). The City’s Vision: May 2005. Tel Aviv: Author (Hebrew).

VALENTINE, G. (1993). “(Hetero)sexing space: Lesbian perceptions and experiences of everyday spaces”. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 11, 395-413.

VALENTINE, G. (1995). “Out and about: Geographies of lesbian landscapes”. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 19 (1), 96-111.

WEIGHTMAN, B. (1980). “Gay bars as private places”. Landscape Research, 24 (1), 9-16.

YASSOUR, A. (2003). “Theories of justice in philosophy”. In: YASSOUR, A., OVED, Y., ROZOLIO, D. and ROZNER, M. (eds.). Social Justice and Equality in a Changing World. Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuchad, 14-88 (Hebrew).

YIFTACHEL, O. (1998). “Planning and social control: Exploring the dark side”. Journal of Planning Literature, 12, 395-406.

YIFTACHEL, O. (2012). “Critical theory and ‘gray space’: Mobilization of the colonized”. In: BRENNER, N., MARCUSE, P. and MAYER, M. (eds.). Cities for People, Not for Profit: Critical Urban Theory and the Right to the City. London and New-York: Routledge, 150-170.

ZIV, A. (2010). “Performative politics in Israeli queer anti-occupation activism”. GLQ: A Journal of Lesbian and Gay Studies, 16 (4), 537-556.